You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
External example: binding editorial sign-off to a timeline and media snapshot
#2092
I'm working on AffixIO and considering a small, independently maintained example for binding an editorial sign-off to a specific timeline and its media. I'd appreciate feedback on the OTIO boundary before building it. This wouldn't add a dependency or approval logic to OTIO itself.
The case is an approved edit that is later trimmed, reordered or relinked to different media. The application should report that the original sign-off no longer matches the supplied inputs, rather than carry an unchanged approved label forward.
My starting point would be an external signed sidecar covering the exact saved .otio bytes and a manifest of content digests for resolved media. Both would come from an immutable snapshot. The signature stays outside the timeline to avoid a circular hash. This deliberately treats a reserialization as a changed artifact; it doesn't attempt semantic equivalence between edits.
I've read the adapter documentation's guidance on namespaced metadata and lossless .otio storage. Other format exports would be separate artifacts requiring a fresh check, not assumed to preserve the evidence. Missing media or evidence would produce an unverified result. This would attest to the sign-off and inputs, not establish copyright ownership, legal clearance or that a render matches the timeline.
Does an application-level wrapper around the existing read/write APIs sound like the right approach, rather than a new adapter? Are there existing projects or conventions for associating review evidence with timeline snapshots that I should use instead?
I haven't implemented or tested this with OTIO yet. I'd keep the first example to synthetic timelines and media, with tests for trimming, relinking and missing evidence.
reacted with thumbs up emoji reacted with thumbs down emoji reacted with laugh emoji reacted with hooray emoji reacted with confused emoji reacted with heart emoji reacted with rocket emoji reacted with eyes emoji
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
I'm working on AffixIO and considering a small, independently maintained example for binding an editorial sign-off to a specific timeline and its media. I'd appreciate feedback on the OTIO boundary before building it. This wouldn't add a dependency or approval logic to OTIO itself.
The case is an approved edit that is later trimmed, reordered or relinked to different media. The application should report that the original sign-off no longer matches the supplied inputs, rather than carry an unchanged approved label forward.
My starting point would be an external signed sidecar covering the exact saved
.otiobytes and a manifest of content digests for resolved media. Both would come from an immutable snapshot. The signature stays outside the timeline to avoid a circular hash. This deliberately treats a reserialization as a changed artifact; it doesn't attempt semantic equivalence between edits.I've read the adapter documentation's guidance on namespaced metadata and lossless
.otiostorage. Other format exports would be separate artifacts requiring a fresh check, not assumed to preserve the evidence. Missing media or evidence would produce an unverified result. This would attest to the sign-off and inputs, not establish copyright ownership, legal clearance or that a render matches the timeline.Does an application-level wrapper around the existing read/write APIs sound like the right approach, rather than a new adapter? Are there existing projects or conventions for associating review evidence with timeline snapshots that I should use instead?
I haven't implemented or tested this with OTIO yet. I'd keep the first example to synthetic timelines and media, with tests for trimming, relinking and missing evidence.
All reactions